Tour Stop 6: General Harrison

Charred Wood & Booze

Hear and smell what it’s like to dig up a buried ship from the gold rush, and find out what was inside. Nearby, discover a major civil rights milestone in California history.

Audio file

---

Chapter 1

Uncovering a Burned Storeship

What did archaeologists find when they dug up the storeship General Harrison?

Transcript

NARRATOR
Look down at the sidewalk, at the northwest corner of Battery and Clay streets. See those gleaming metal curves embedded in the concrete? These outline the location beneath your feet of a ship called General Harrison that's been buried here since the 1850s. The tiny metal T shapes are copper nails, an artistic representation of the ones taken from the ship's hull. For the full story of how a ship ends up buried in the middle of a city, visit stop number five, one block west of here. But here's a quick summary. 

The cargo ship General Harrison arrived in San Francisco in 1850. The ship's crew ran off to join the rush for gold. So the owners hauled the ship as far as they could up into the mudflats then converted it into a warehouse for arriving cargo. Eventually, the city grew out into the mud flats and surrounded the ship. Then when a massive fire swept through and destroyed the neighborhood in 1851, the remains were buried and the city rebuilt on top. It wasn't until 150 years later, in September 2001, that under guidance of archaeologists, the ship was unearthed by construction crews preparing the building that's here today. Maritime archaeologist Jim Delgado was part of the team working that day.

JAMES DELGADO
I arrived on the scene just after General Harrison had started to be exposed, from the burnt-off tops of its ribs, or its frames, where it had burned to the waterline in May of 1851. General Harrison gradually emerged from the mud tightly built, heavy, thick wooden ribs still covered with planks on both sides.

NARRATOR
As the General Harrison reemerged, the crew couldn't help but notice a few distinctive smells, says archaeologist Rhonda Robichaud. 

RHONDA ROBICHAUD 
You had this heavy smell of charred wood.

NARRATOR
A smell still lingering from when the ship burned in the Great Fire of 1851.

RHONDA ROBICHAUD  
Interestingly, there must have been a lot of wine in the General Harrison because it smelt like charred wood and booze.

NARRATOR 
Archeologists also began finding evidence of what had happened after the fire, washing away the mud. They found a thick iron pry bar and a stack of iron bolts nearby. Also around was a broken rice bowl, a shattered bottle, and several pairs of worn out boots. It looked like a crew of workers had just left.

JAMES DELGADO
Somebody had cut two doorways into each side down low where ramps had come in and goods had been pulled out.

NARRATOR
They also noticed that the copper and brass fittings in the ship were all missing—clear evidence that salvagers had spent time here reclaiming these valuable metals.

RHONDA ROBICHAUD 
They first cleared all of the cargo out from the hold where burnt and unburnt just went over the sides into the shallows of the Bay so that they could get at the copper fastenings on the ship. So they took all of the copper and all of the brass.

NARRATOR 
The archaeology team concluded that the professional ship salvager Charles Hare had sent his crew of mostly Chinese workers to recover these metals. To hear more about the ship salvage business visit stop number 11, the site of Charles Hares shipyard.

The archaeologists also dug through the pile of half burned cargo dumped next to the ship.

JAMES DELGADO 
And there in a mound alongside the ship—as we began to peel it away, using not just a backhoe, but with hoses that carefully melted the thick amalgam of mud and creosote from burned wood—we began to reveal a pile of broken and half melted glass, and in it all sorts of things, some of which were perfectly preserved. I'll remember forever a wooden box with its lid still attached. And as we washed away the mud and exposed this crate, and realizing it was a wine box, were able to lift the three planks and find 12 bottles, a few of them broken, but the others intact, still packed in straw, and with the corks still in place in the neck of each bottle, and filled with their liquid contents. We know from analysis that it was a very fine white wine, most likely a chardonnay from France.

NARRATOR
They unearthed bottles of brandy, sherry, and champagne, and samples of what might have been pâté. Other surprises included bolts of charred cloth, fused and melted kegs of nails and tacks, sacks of beans and barley, a bag of bright red glass beads. These were likely goods ready to be sold from the storeship at the time it burned.

JAMES DELGADO
The General Harrison in many ways was set up in some fashion as Costco is today, with goods that might not sell in bulk immediately loaded down below in the hole. In the 'tween deck area, more accessible to people, there you would have the goods that they expected would move quickly. But you also had up on the top main deck, covered over by the structure that housed the vessel, you had a bunch of benches—and there, an auctioneer would be on hand to say, "Today just in! The ship Magnolia from Boston. I have 150 lots of shovels. What am I bid gentleman?"  

NARRATOR
Newspaper ads from the time list goods being sold at the General Harrison—a glimpse into the economy of early San Francisco.

RHONDA ROBICHAUD
One of them that was advertising assaying goods, crucibles, hard tax shovels—so everything that you would need to go to the Gold Rush. And that same advertisement had children's coats and silk shawls because original colonists had been here 100 years and so they had families.

NARRATOR 
Looking back on the dig, archaeologist Jim Delgado wondered how the ship and its cargo could be in relatively good condition when the fire had burned every building to the ground.

JAMES DELGADO 
If a ship is caught in a fire that's burning with such intensity that a thick wooden hull is being consumed and turned to ash, where buildings are literally vaporizing, where men are baked to death inside brick buildings with iron shutters, and where metal is melting because the temperatures are reaching thousands of degrees. How is it that wooden boxes are in charge and that straw is still wrapping bottles that are inside those boxes and that clothing—be it completely sewn or blanks where you could get stacks of what would become shirts or skirts or pants—are still lying in there along with burlap sacks and they've not been turned to a crisp? How does this happen? Well, what happens is that in the midst of a fire on the water, the least amount of water coming in as the ship leaks and as it burns is turned to steam, and steam expands at well over 1,000 to one, I think almost 1,900 to one. So a gallon of water that leaks in is going to be turned into this massive cloud of steam which has the effect of smothering any flaming piece of debris that falls inside the ship. And as well the heat is drawn naturally to the water outside the vessel.

NARRATOR
We may not have heard the last of the General Harrison because the 2001 excavation only uncovered the stern portion of the ship. The bow remains entombed beneath the two story building at 432 Clay Street. Someday no doubt real estate developers will decide to raze and rebuild on that lot. And another crew of archaeologists might just get a whiff of charred wood, booze, and a glimpse of life during the Gold Rush.

Audio file

---

Chapter 2

Archy Lee’s Fight For Freedom

How a Black man from Mississippi became the focal point for California’s legal debate over slavery.

Transcript

NARRATOR
Just one block north of here at Battery and Washington streets, a judge in 1858 made the final ruling in perhaps California's most famous court battle over slavery. California was a free state from the time it joined the Union in 1850. But the limits of California slavery ban were tested in three different courts by the case of a Black man from Mississippi named Archy Lee. 

In October 1857, enslaver Charles Stovall traveled from Mississippi to California hoping to improve his health. He brought enslaved African American man Archy Lee with him to Sacramento. Soon after arriving, Stovall set up a home-based school for children and began "hiring" Archy out to do kitchen work, pocketing the proceeds for himself. 

The following January, Stovall decided to head back to Mississippi and force Lee to come with him. As he and Lee were about to leave Sacramento, Lee escaped. He knew that his only chance at freedom was in California. He was soon found and arrested. When Archy Lee's case came before Sacramento County Court Judge Robert Robertson, Stovall claimed that because he was a citizen of Mississippi and only visiting California, the ban on slavery did not apply to him or Archy Lee. He also claimed the Lee did not even want to be free. When Lee was called into the courtroom, he told Judge Robertson, "I don't understand what you're speaking of, but I want it to come out right. I don't want to go back to Mississippi." 

Ultimately, Judge Robertson ruled in Lee's favor, describing his logic this way:

HISTORIC QUOTE
 "If a man may sojourn here two months and work his slave, why may he not stay 20 years and work 20 slaves? The principle is precisely the same. The law would not permit a citizen of this state to hold and work a slave against his consent."

NARRATOR
Lee was released. However, Stovall immediately appealed to the California Supreme Court and within hours, Lee was back behind bars. Two of the three Supreme Court judges having grown up in the South were defenders of slavery. So although they had to uphold California's anti-slavery constitution, in this case, they decided to make an exception.

HISTORIC QUOTE  
"This is the first case that has occurred under the existing law and under these circumstances, we are not disposed to rigidly enforce the rule for the first time."

NARRATOR
By this point. thousands of Californians were following Archy Lee's case, including many anti-slavery activists who were determined to free Lee before he could be taken back to Mississippi. Stovall kidnapped Lee into hiding. But soon there was a rumor that Stovall planned to leave with Lee on March 4th on a steamer called the Orizaba. San Francisco police officers and the sheriff were recruited and together they boarded the boat as it left the waterfront. There was no sign of Stovall or Archy Lee. But as the steamer headed for the Golden Gate, the officers saw a rowboat approaching with several men aboard. Officer Isaiah Lees saw that this was his chance to help free Archy Lee.

HISTORIC QUOTE 
The boat was close enough that Lees could jump down and grab Archy. Confusion erupted. Stovall said the Supreme Court had given Archy to him, and he'd "be god damned" if any other court would take him away from him. He glared at Officer Lees, threatening to blow the "top of his head off," but Lees calmly continued his duties. Archy was trembling when Lees picked him up and passed him up to Deputy Sheriff Thompson.

NARRATOR
In a few weeks, Archy Lee's case was heard yet again in the U.S. District Court in San Francisco, at a courthouse that stood at Battery and Washington streets. This time, on April 14, the judge ruled in Archy Lee's favor. He was released into the hands of African American activists who had raised the money for his defense and fought for his release. They helped him take his final step to freedom—a ticket on a ship bound for Vancouver, a free Canadian city where yet another gold rush was just getting started.

Going Further

Discover More about the General Harrison

Other resources about the buried ship General Harrison and Archy Lee: